Showing posts with label Ancients. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ancients. Show all posts

Monday, 26 October 2026

'Brythunian Border Chase #2 ... Where is Conan?'

 More action from part #2 of the 'Hyboria Campaign' with 'Battle Command Ancients & Medieval'. (Otherwise known as 'what you do when you have completely random but small collections of old 25mm Ancients & Medievals'...) The forces are based heavily upon the old 1975 FGU publication 'Royal Armies of the Hyborian Age' by Lin Carter. with Campaign ladder and main ideas from 'Maudlin Jack Tarr's' excellent blog. 

An argument over the Princess's credit card bill

 Brythunian mercenaries appear to have probed further into Nemedia, chasing the force that managed to rescue Princess Zamora last time (Clearly with that turncoat Conan's help). 

Best set of rules for this kind of thing...
Nemedians have retained most of their core knights, and Brythunians have kept most of their pike and heavy infantry...The Nemedians, despite having a good defensive position, suffered terribly on their flank, even having to bring mounted Nobles (Knights from the opposite flank) to help. 

A true classic

 Brythunian medium cavalry stared at the foot knights on their right flank most of the day, all the action happening on the centre and left.Conan, as previously, threatened and postured greatly at the start of battle, then retired to the village for a wine or three. 

How it should have ended?
He appeared at game start, then no further initiative ties meant that he watched from a safe distance...I begin to doubt his convictions (or maybe he and Princess Zamora were 'busy'...playing dice of course..where is your filthy mind?).


The Brythunian mercenary contingent, now deep in Nemedian territory, and still annoyed...

yeah...keep an eye on that left flank attack

Knights face Brythunian pike in the centre...now someone is going to get a bloody nose...

The developing Brythiunian left...carnage begins

On the right, ensconced knights welcome Conan in - who does nothing for the rest of the battle, while both sides stare at each other

Lots of action on the left as high ground is taken and lost, Nemedian archers do considerable damage, and cavalry sets up for charging

Staring...staring...not moving

Brythunian pike advance steadily in the centre..Nemedian attacks hold great potential, but bounce off

The Nemedians, losing 4 units on their right flank, now send in the heavies


It doesn't end well


Next time...a river defence...deeeeep in Nemedia. Conan buggers off, ...presumably with Princess Zamora. He will be back - but on whose side?
Next time...there will even be arrows on a map...honest...



Thursday, 2 April 2026

Punic Wars Battle - with 'Battle Command: Ancients & Medieval'

Last post, I talked about ‘Midgard Heroic Battles’, with the promise that we would do the same battle with the Piquet/FoB3 based: ‘Battle Command: Ancients and Medieval’ (BCAM) by Brent Oman/Piquet Wargames.

Again, I offer the compare-and-contrast style previously completed for ‘Field of Battle vs  Volley and Bayonet’ Both sets target similar periods (or at least play-styles as Midgard has more fantasy elements and sorcery etc.) but deliver very different experiences.

Midgard explicitly embraces a “heroic deeds” ethos, with systems for battle, heroes and reputation at work - inspired by sagas and legends. BCAM spans Biblical-era wars through the Wars of the Roses and stays firmly historical with a strong emphasis on command friction and fog of war, evolving from DNA and mechanics of the Field of Battle/Piquet family.

I just played the Punic Wars scenario again  – much more tense, more drama, more to and fro of initiative. Excellent game, right to the wire…

Core Philosophy and Feel

  • Midgard is narrative-driven and cinematic. Heroes are game-changers who lead from the front, perform Mighty Deeds, and can duel enemy champions. Battles are designed to feel epic and heroic — charging your warlord into the fray is  encouraged and decisive. Reputation (victory points) is tied directly to preserving the army’s prestige and the heroes’ glory.
  • BCAM is a command simulation. Leadership quality, card decks, and the Action Matrix create constant friction and tough choices. It’s less about individual heroics and more about managing an army under imperfect information and limited control. The feel is closer to a gritty, decision-heavy historical recreation — broad-brush but tactically rich.  

The feel is very different – but the tense play definitely came from BCAM today. Midgard does give Hollywood/Iliad heroism; but BCAM offers command chaos and actual drama.

 

Activation and Turn Sequence

  • Midgard: Semi-alternating IGOUGO with an Attacker/Defender role
    1. Mighty Deeds phase (heroes refresh points).
    2. Attacker moves
    3. Melee (including hero single combats).
    4. Defender repeats movement + melee.
    5. Alternating missile fire. Units can become fatigued (fewer moves) as stamina drops.
  • BCAM: Card-driven, non-linear sequence (core Piquet/Field of Battle DNA). Each side has a small deck (8–9 cards). Initiative, leadership quality (CiC rating), and the new Action Matrix determine what you can do (less randomness – more choice).
  • Cards offer primary actions (Move, Melee, Infantry Fire, etc.) plus secondary options via the Matrix.
  • You constantly choose where to focus limited command pips — whole army, a command group, or a single unit. Multiple decisions and built-in friction.

Critical take: Midgard is smoother and more predictable, though has many systems operating on different ‘wavelengths’. BCAM is more tense and re-playable for players who love  “what do I do – what can I do -  with this card?” moments.

BCAM’s system reduces downtime compared to older FoB systems. There is some administrative overhead, but it's quite unique.

Combat and Morale

  • Midgard: Units roll Combat Dice (based on type/quality). Hits must equal or exceed the target’s Armour value to cause Stamina loss (basically HP). Fresh vs. depleted units matter. Support saves, secondary/supporting units in melee, and hero interventions add depth. Morale is baked into reputation and stamina.
  • BCAM: Opposed dice with modifiers, armour classes, and UI attrition (like Field of Battle). Skirmishers and evasion are more nuanced for ancients. Pursuit rules and morale checks feel grittier…and battle is bloody, gaps open up, and you have to command the army, not hero systems.

BCAM gives more granular period flavour (especially light troops and missile fire).

 

Victory Conditions

  • Midgard: Reputation-based. Start with 8–10+ tokens. Lose them when units rout or heroes die. First to zero reputation (or most at scenario end) loses. It elegantly rewards heroic preservation and punishes reckless hero deaths, but the system needs to managed in game.
  • BCAM: Classic Piquet-style army morale/break point via cumulative UI losses and morale checks triggered by cards.

Midgard’s system feels more “heroic”; BCAM’s is more attritional and realistic.

 Midgard captures the “heroic age” element. Lots of systems/traits/dice/hero elemnts, but tactically deep once mastered.. Encourages aggressive, characterful play. There are some gamey systems – many traits and d6 systems (re-roll 1s, 5 and 6s hit etc. etc.) – systems not always intuitive. Needs multiple plays to manage systems. There are more modern systems akin to Warhammer Ancient Battles, Hail Caesar, or Dragon Rampant.

Battle Command: Ancients and Medieval: Outstanding command-and-control simulation. Always intuitive. The Action Matrix creates constant meaningful decisions. Excellent fog-of-war feel (always a bonus). Solo-friendly. Scales well across the entire ancient/medieval spectrum with period-specific tweaks (evasion, skirmish). Demands more plays - realistic command friction, tough tactical choices every turn, and a system that rewards clever use of limited resources.

Both are strong modern rulesets that avoid (most of the) bloat of older systems. BCAM is superb if you already love the engine.


Early cavalry action on the Roman left

Some of the Roman units are unstoppable - the Carthaginians avoid them where possible


Gauls pushed back on the left, despite their willingness to press the attack

'ELE-CAM'


Carthaginian pressure...as Romans fare poorly on their right

Gauls suffer on the Carthaginian left, and their commander goes down



The Gauls on the Carthaginian left have been all but stopped - with a dead commander. Greek mercs hold the centre against a strong Roman counter-attack.

 

'Diskoball the Mighty!'

'Havnoball' the squeaky

'Bothballs' goes down

Elephants still very active despite losses - they have only broken once...causing minor devastation

Greek Mercs on the Roman right

Severe pressure on the Roman left and in the centre, as Greek mercs move and stop the Roman juggernaut - critical times, as Army Morale runs out for the Romans

By game end, a close run thing, the Carthaginians force the Roman centre to break, and a withdrawl of the remaining force. Another excellent game.

 

Tuesday, 31 March 2026

Punic Wars test battle - with 'Midgard: Heroic Battles'

With the superb marketing strategy, and widespread push to develop a following in the 'game-o-sphere', I eventually succumbed and bought 'Midgard Heroic Battles' (I watched all the youtube videos and was convinced).

For the test game, we used 20mm plastics -- of which I am finding loads more each day ...

 

My reasoning was that now that I am consolidating all my 'Sword & Sorcery' lead pile and ancients plastics (though not an ancients gamer, I seem, to have collected a veritable shedload of 20mm Airfix, Hat and Italeri ancients over the years), I was looking for a single unifying ruleset. My thought had been to use 'Battle Command Ancients & Medieval' (effectively Piquet : Field of Battle variant), though the lure of Midgard was too strong, though Battle Command will get well tried too.

 

The Roman centre holds steady throughout

That said, it is a unique approach in many respects, more traditional in others. It will take several plays to get used to all the moving parts that are at work. The most efficient machine has few moving parts, that is not to say that the 'machine with many parts' does not give the best performance(?!) - though it can of course require the most maintenance - and depending on the system, parts might not always be required  (stretching this analogy until it snaps!!! in terms of car design -  AdBlue tank...Ah'm lookin' at you!). 

Cavalry attack on the Roman right flank

There are a number of different systems operating simultaneously in the game, necessitating an approach which rewards expertise in all, to get the best from gameplay:

  • Attacks in the centre - the charging mechanisms are most satisfying

    Combat is relatively simple, and works off 'buckets 'o' d6'. Now normally, this makes me scream, but seemed to work ok here.
    I mentioned d6 right?
  •  'Heroes' and leaders can lead units, affect combat, challenge other heroes, and generally use leadership 'stuff' which affects play. They can use 'mighty deeds' as a resource to influence command and combat.
  • Command tests are excellently done- a flat 3+, but the need for command tests varies - i.e. 2nd move, or restraint from pursuit etc.
  • Traits can affect everything from rewarding full strength units charging through to command test re-rolls. Again, this makes the difference between bland units and suitable characteristics for your favourite ancient or fantasy unit . normally I dislike traits (Slack Chowder for instance), but they really work here. 
  •  A 'reputation' numberis ground down if leaders do not accept personal combats, and do not 'lead' effectively, and due to losses in combat...this was where we missed a few things, but once understood, there is a great system here.
  • Gameplay is rewarded by being conversant with all of these systems, so the game will take a few plays to get used to. 

To and fro on the Roman left - with the centre and right holding


Roman epic push in the centre - but it will not be enough to guarantee victory today


The Roman right flank, holds, as the Romans threaten to push the Carthaginian al;lies back to the start-line


Hero and unit match-ups on the Roman right


Scattered combats in the centre

Down to the last reputation point, the Carthaginian allies outflank the Roman centre, who had pushed just that bit too far forward