Now this is a nice set of rules.
If you’re not aware of this one, the concept is operational (The Soviet
‘Operational Art’, as quoted - actually, I’ve had Tim Gow’s rulebook since the
90s and only getting around to playing it now! Maybe I’m the one that’s not
aware…doh!). The rules may be pretty hard to find now, but the concepts are lovely.
In essence we’re dealing with stands of infantry which represent entire
battalions, where 4cm=1km (or half that in 1/300). (…as Bolt Action fans run
away screaming…). Tank bases can represent multiples of companies.
So, we’re looking at the sort of level we normally see in Hex’n’Chit
wargames. The beauty of this is that I’ve always wanted to do Market Garden on
an 8’x5’ table, with 20mm miniatures. Pull up the distance between Eindhoven
and Arnhem on google and you’ll see how it fits.
Highlights include:
- The SMART orders system (Static, Mobile, Attack, Retreat, Transit). This is the focus of the game and dictates movement, readiness for combat etc. Outguess your opponent and manage your resources. This is what WW2 gaming should really be about.
- Relative strengths dictate all differentiation between units, and degrading strengths are kept hidden from opponents – with them rolling to see how many hits they take from the dice you hand them.
- To this end, Recon elements are used properly, to assess actual strengths, actual orders etc. A lovely fog of war concept, (though the counters I used for strength and orders were too big, and strewn across the table like so much confetti at one stage).
- Logistics (in terms of both supplies and fuel) is critical to protracted battles. If you can’t trace your supply route, and use up the lorries’ supplies appropriately (yes, trucks are really important), you degrade your capability fast (like ZOCs and supply in the old SPI games).
- Combat at the sharp end is close up and personal and protracted – there are no ranges for infantry and vehicles at this level and artillery is on the table (yay). It’s what happening behind the lines that can make a big difference. Don’t get hung up on the fight at the crossroads – support it, withdraw, or look at supply issues that are coming.
- Bombing and air support and the concepts used in blitzkrieg start to work, and key – you understand ‘why’ they worked.
- Here’s a pretentious point. You aren’t managing the battlefield here, you’re managing the ‘battlespace’ (to coin an oft used more modern term). You’re concerned about the front, supporting that front, potential breakthroughs which hit your flank or rear, and supply…oh, like things a real general would worry about you say? Yep.
All that said, we probably didn’t give the rules the outing they
require, with no real urban combat (which sucks up supplies likes nobody’s
business), and I know we made some mistakes in terms of logistics. That’s no
bad thing, as the rules are eminently hackable (in fact the format positively
encourages house ‘rulings’).
There are of course some very pertinent links
Tim Gow’s (the author) blog:
Tim Gow’s (the author) blog:
Bob Cordery’s blog – which has some relevant rules hacks (HexBlitz),
and has some great development rules concepts. My reason for citing this one is
that I have hexes on the gamespace in the pics below, which will of course lend themselves to dictating
movement and range etc.for future runs.
The Megablitz website:
Steve’s Balagan blog, with some nice quick reference sheets and rules
clarifications and scenarios. Actually it was his Eastern Front version of ‘Dot
sur la Mappe’ that we used for the game.
The long road east. Minimum terrain, but at this scale, it's unimportant as range issues are handled very differently.
On board elements, awaiting 16th Panzer, make first moves toward the farm complex..
...as 16th Panzer division make drive toward east.
Still some way to go, but 'most' of the division is on the road now.
Recon elements, supported by armour, makes for the left flank, where Soviet units are thought to be.
...in the form of a second JU88 mission.
Armour closes to contact.
As the fight at the road junctions becomes desperate.
In the final assault, enough damage is done such that German units are able to advance while carrying out a holding action at the junctions...and there are still air options available to support.
All in all, this was pretty exciting as a concept, and there are some good
hacks of the ideas lurking about the net. A large battle can be fought in a matter of hours, with the important issues of the day being stressed.
Market Garden, Bastogne etc – all eminently do-able with nice 20mm models
and good game resource management – just what we like. A modern version, along
the lines of Avalon Hill’s ‘Tac Air’ springs to mind, and some larger Vietnam
scenarios from ‘Seven Firefights in Vietnam’ are applicable depending on how
you adapt the SMART concept for company level etc.
Having had the hexes in place, it also made me think about how I can use them to hack the existing rules, or use a little of the 'Hexblitz' system too, and even parts of Memoir '44.
With hexes, we can see the combat unfold as above - like a Hex'n'Chit game with toys.
Also? Well, I took a leaf out of the Megablitz veteran’s book and put
some of the vehicles and infantry on thick bases with a black edge – more reminiscent
of large unit markers than pieces in a diorama…oh, they look nice now.
Love those black lines...
More to follow…
This is a game I've always wanted to try - an operational level game on the tabletop! Very nice review, Darren. I must, MUST try these.
ReplyDeleteThere looks to be a similar (maybe similar?) game: "NATO Brigade Commander" that takes it into the modern realm? Or am I confusing apples and oranges??
Actually, I was thinking of using your 'Battle' turn sequence as a hack of some of the Megablitz rules for the Arnhem game with hexes - so I might be sending you an email or two :)
DeleteNATO Brigade commander is by the same author I think (Tim Gow). I think he's withdrawn it from his blog for a re-write, but it looked excellent in some of his posts.
http://megablitzandmore.blogspot.co.uk/2010/02/nato-brigade-commander-rules.html
Great to see somebody else give my Dot in Russia variant a go. As it happens I'm probably going to replay it in the very near future.
ReplyDeleteGreat to hear from you sir. Not only did I use your scenario variant, but also your quick reference sheet and your combat results pdf. I got a lot more guidance on the game through your blog before we played, so very useful.
DeleteThanks again, and I look forward to seeing more Megablitz on your excellent blog.
That looks a splendid game - I am now suitably embarrassed about how much time has elapsed since I last ran a MB game...
ReplyDeleteThanks Tim. Great concepts here.
DeleteAre you working on a second edition (with a Market Garden scenario pack) by any chance? :)
Hi Duc
ReplyDeleteI too have had Megablitz in collection since initial publication but never got around to using them !!!
Yep. They're very different to what we're used to - and makes gameplay different too. Real concern over resources etc.
DeleteThanks for posting this, very interesting, don't see too many operational games. What do you think about the suitability of SMART orders for solo gaming?
ReplyDeleteV/R,
Jack
Thanks Jack,
DeleteI've been thinking about the SMART orders system a lot for other 'levels' of game, and it could be adapted. I was thinking 'modern' actually in terms of orders given at battalion - even platoon level.
I take your point - operational characteristics of a certain 'army' could be such that they issue certain orders under certain circumstances - due to lack of radios and/or doctrine (WarPac, VC ?).
Megablitz is available on eBay; a trader in Nottingham seems to have acquired Duncan Macfarlane's stock. Search for Arcane Hobbies IIRC. Selling for £8 (£10 when published).
ReplyDeleteNBC is a different animal with a lower level representation.
There is an unofficial "Modern Megablitz" set in the files section of the MB Yahoo group, same rules but has a stab at EW, chemical weapons etc.
Some modern games can be run using standard MB; check out Tim's 1967 Arab-Israeli orbats.
This is a period I'm working at doing in "20mm" mostly using 1/87 toys with 20mm figures, also hoping to actually play the rules!
Nice kit BTW.
Thanks Neil
DeleteVery useful info here.
Excellent battle report - for a moment I thought that you were using Tim's toys when I saw the converted SdKfz 231. You might also enjoy the long-running Barbarossa campaign over at NQM
ReplyDeletehttps://notquitemechanised.wordpress.com/the-great-patriotic-war/
Regards, Chris.
Thanks for this Chris. Appreciate your comments.
DeleteI have been looking at your blog. Also becoming a big fan of NQM.