Of course, this is where the pics on this post looks very similar to the previous one. That's Squad Leader for you; not a lot of variation in how it actually looks (at least in the first three scenarios), but of course, that's the 'minor' letdown with hex'n'chit games vs miniature wargames, right?
Nevertheless, the Dzerzhinsky Tractor Works scenario can get pretty exciting. Experience had told me though, that is was either an early cakewalk for the German engineers trying to break in...or a damned nightmare as the Russians stream across the board, darting from building to building, after forcing a blind spot in the German crossfire.
Still a wonderful system and deserving of a miniatures treatment. The jury is still out though on whether to use the actual counters to represent squads and weapons on a miniature base - or do something else. Of course, counters are easiest, though perhaps less pleasing to the eye.
The Germans get into the Tractor Works early, with a few nice moves through the covering smoke.
(Damn those 8-3-8s and their high morale...)
They hold and dig in, refusing to move despite some accurate Russian fire and the onslaught of a few berserk units (a lot of 'snake eyes' being rolled on this one).
Still an elegant system. I did think during the game, that the mechanics could be turned to WWIII and modern - but of course we have 'Fire Team' and 'Team Yankee' for that ;)
***
In other news, Steve over at 'Sound Officers Call' has an excellent set of old school Horse and Musket rules to try out - based on Charles Grant's The Wargame. Another set of rules for the gaming magpies to try...and these look really good.
'Old skool' lends itself to adding bits and pieces. Already, ideas like allowing commanders a command radius to allow re-rolls have been discussed. Simple, yet effective. Can't wait to try 'em.
...I may also have a post about 'speed' painting soon...beware!
Monday, 23 February 2015
Game 26 - The Tractor Works
Sunday, 25 January 2015
Game 25 - The Guards' Counterattack
The title of the scenario will be familiar to many of course.
It was sad to hear of the recent passing of John Hill, designer of 'Johnny Reb' and the older (and classic) 'Squad Leader'. Re-opening the old SL box brought back a lot of memories, as I'm sure it would for many of us. I can still say with conviction, that this was the only board style wargame in my collection, that I have played every scenario for, at least once.
Those same rules have of course come in for a knock in recent years - with complaints of too much detail, too 'little' detail, the wrong approach to WW2, the wrong scale for WW2, lack of fog of war, etc. etc. etc.
The modern answer to the fog of war problem at least, appears to be card activation or dice activation, which leaves many people (including me) cold.
So it was with new eyes that we took a fresh look at the old classic...and also I took particular interest in Steve's comments over at Sound Officers' Call, who outlined beautifully how the rules mechanisms can echo actual military thinking and tactical initiative, especially so with a view to the conduct of fire and movement.
For those detractors who allude to the lack of 'fog of war' or other issues, the fact remains that it is neither adequately simulated by cards or dice activations - let's face it. Having potential control over all of the counters on the board means very little when faced with whether to activate a unit in terms of 'prep fire' or leave it to move and engage a flank, or keep it in reserve. It's that aspect of the rules which allows the player to make tactical battlefield decisions..and yet, makes it so difficult to make the right decision. That is, in essence, the mainstay of the game. Sure, you can activate every unit on the board. But making the wrong call can have disastrous effects.
Some of the elegant mechanisms we found in this replay of the old classic included:
You can't argue with these mechanics, and to see them all still working thirty years after I last played them (and understanding their design intent much more clearly now) is very refreshing.
Miniatures games (for which the rules were originally designed until Avalon Hill insisted on a board/hex wargame) will follow. There's also a version for miniatures here:
https://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/slminiatures/info
Rest in Peace John.
Early weight of smg fire is devastating on the defending Germans.
Avoiding crossfires from what was essentially a 'beautiful' defensive setup also allows the Russian guards to make inroads into the German buildings.
By mid game, the ability of the Soviets to set up their own crossfires and keep German broken units under 'desperation morale' allows them to almost move around the battlefield at will.
By game end, moving Russian units, who have effectively silenced the last of the machine gun platoons in the German buildings, are able to capture enough ground to win the game.
Excellent rules...glad to see them once again.
It was sad to hear of the recent passing of John Hill, designer of 'Johnny Reb' and the older (and classic) 'Squad Leader'. Re-opening the old SL box brought back a lot of memories, as I'm sure it would for many of us. I can still say with conviction, that this was the only board style wargame in my collection, that I have played every scenario for, at least once.
Those same rules have of course come in for a knock in recent years - with complaints of too much detail, too 'little' detail, the wrong approach to WW2, the wrong scale for WW2, lack of fog of war, etc. etc. etc.
The modern answer to the fog of war problem at least, appears to be card activation or dice activation, which leaves many people (including me) cold.
So it was with new eyes that we took a fresh look at the old classic...and also I took particular interest in Steve's comments over at Sound Officers' Call, who outlined beautifully how the rules mechanisms can echo actual military thinking and tactical initiative, especially so with a view to the conduct of fire and movement.
For those detractors who allude to the lack of 'fog of war' or other issues, the fact remains that it is neither adequately simulated by cards or dice activations - let's face it. Having potential control over all of the counters on the board means very little when faced with whether to activate a unit in terms of 'prep fire' or leave it to move and engage a flank, or keep it in reserve. It's that aspect of the rules which allows the player to make tactical battlefield decisions..and yet, makes it so difficult to make the right decision. That is, in essence, the mainstay of the game. Sure, you can activate every unit on the board. But making the wrong call can have disastrous effects.
Some of the elegant mechanisms we found in this replay of the old classic included:
- The decision to 'prep fire' and leave the unit static with a base of fire is heavily dependent on how many broken units can be brought back to the battle in the rally phase. It's easy in the early turns, but as units start to melt away...it takes nerves of steel to commit your troops to early action...even if you can get them back in play.
- Risk is inherent every time you move.
- No other game simulates the pressure on individual squad leaders and platoon leaders - with the resultant effects of them being broken or killed - which can be catastrophic (I'm including IABSM here).
- No other game adequately places the focus on support weapons, their breakdown and potential capture by the enemy. In addition, their enhanced range can have major effects on the battle.
- The averaging effect of 2D6 and the requisite bell curve means that when less probable rolls happen (as in our game - twice) the effects can be devastating. The trick is to follow up early enough and exploit the relative weakness on the other side.
- The scale is perfect for WWII. Other rules seem to 'scale' on the basis of offering a gameable scenario through making exceptions or fudging MMGs etc. etc., though Squad Leader trumps them in terms of making the player really feel like the company commander - losing touch with named commanders feels terrible, while watching them advance as the position is taken is momentous.
- (The only annoying episode was when I couldn't read 'Sgt Kelso' or any of the other leader's names on their counter, without a bright light and my glasses. Thirty years ago, this wasn't a problem !!!)
You can't argue with these mechanics, and to see them all still working thirty years after I last played them (and understanding their design intent much more clearly now) is very refreshing.
Miniatures games (for which the rules were originally designed until Avalon Hill insisted on a board/hex wargame) will follow. There's also a version for miniatures here:
https://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/slminiatures/info
Rest in Peace John.
Early weight of smg fire is devastating on the defending Germans.
Avoiding crossfires from what was essentially a 'beautiful' defensive setup also allows the Russian guards to make inroads into the German buildings.
By mid game, the ability of the Soviets to set up their own crossfires and keep German broken units under 'desperation morale' allows them to almost move around the battlefield at will.
By game end, moving Russian units, who have effectively silenced the last of the machine gun platoons in the German buildings, are able to capture enough ground to win the game.
Excellent rules...glad to see them once again.
Sunday, 28 December 2014
Game 24 - Lightning War
Like most wargamers, I cut my teeth on the table of modifers,
the roll of the d6 with variable plusses and minuses and the complicated
artillery rules. This has been a mainstay of wargaming since the heyday of the
70s and 80s.
I’m talking about Firefly, Command Decision and even Rapid Fire here and I suspect (from what I’ve seen) that the latest version of ‘Fires
of Conflict’ and its ilk, uses similar systems in a decidedly ‘non’ unique way.
So that said, I was surprised about eight years ago (and have recently been 're'surprised when I re-discovered them) with a
completely free set which I found on the internet. Now, there appears to be a
bit of a chequered history here, so bear with…
The rules are called ‘Lightning War’ by David St.Clair and
Andrew O’Gorman. These later became ‘Lightning War II’ with added orders and objective rules. A later version, with
VERY similar systems by 'David Childs Dennis' also appeared under the ‘Lightning
War’ title, though these were both modern and WWII versions of rules at a much
lower and ‘close in’ scale (covering areas such as Russian conflicts and more
recently world war II).
So the game that follows is very much using the original
rules – with minimal fuss and bother – dating from the 2002 pdf. (I can email
these to anyone who wants them, as the original rules seem to have disappeared from the internet, and been replaced by the reduced scale versions).
Here are some examples of the beautiful design:
- Game turn sequence revolves around initiative (nothing strange there) though you can grant it to the opposing player if you want to force him to move (or miss a move).
- Units that don’t move (on both sides) fire before units that do – granting a ‘reserve fire’ rule without the messiness of stopping units mid move.
- There are 3 movement lengths and ranges – 6”, 12” and 24”. The Grognards among you will be gasping with shock, but this doesn’t half speed things up.
- Gun effectiveness vs armour governs the number of dice fired, with ‘6’s predominat. That’s it. No modifers or mess.
- Artillery at the company scale is assumed to range across the table, hence no ranging, with the ‘to hit’ roll built into the number of d6 rolled. Get caught in the open by the side that has initiative, and your units are badly mauled.
- Armour caught in the open without infantry support, is automatically removed if close assaulted by infantry, if they survive first fire. You're forced to support your armour without having to write complex rules around it.
The second version of the rules introduces objectives and
orders, but again in a seamless way. We’ll try this next time.
Here’s the kicker though. This game proceeded in exactly the
same manner as a more complex game, with better appreciation of the tactics
required and more careful use of forces available in half the time. Take that hardback rules!!!
Russian armour makes an attack on the right as the remnants strike deep on the left flank.
Armour in action, taking out one panther at some cost, as the JS2 lurks.
German defences take a battering on the left and right as Soviet armour starts to break through.
Some sterling efforts (with lucky sixes ;) ) in defence and the German re-establish the line in the town with one anti tank gun and a panther.
The 75mm ATG holds the line, reducing the last of the Soviet armour, so much so that German infantry (which has been spotting for artillery) can be released to press home a counterattack...
All in all a lovely and fast set of rules that pull no
punches, get a more readily achievable result and hone tactical use of troops
rather than book flipping. I love it.
The big benefit here is that the same mechanisms can be used
for
- Moderns and 1980s Cold War
- Other scales. Currently, 3-4 infanty units represent a company, but smaller scale squad or platoon level, rather than company, are readily achievable by adjusting ranges and clarifying command issues. Even breaking bases down to fireteam level offers ultra modern opportunities.
- Upscaling to operational level for ‘Market Garden’ or Bulge also makes sense, and retains a playable ruleset where logistical concerns are key.
More next time…and Happy New Year to all.
Sunday, 2 November 2014
Game 23 - Walcourt, 1689
This scenario is straight out of the 'Pike and Shotte' adaptation of 'Black Powder'. The main reason behind doing this game was to gain some familiarity with these popular rules (there aren't that many differences between the two sets, bar obvious period concerns). The scenario itself makes a few changes re. the actual battle/history - which suits the figures I had anyway (Irish as allied troops in 1689 etc.).
Overall, the rules give a decent game - so we were less concerned with the actual history on this occasion, hoping to find a set of rules that could ultimately be used for the American War of Independence (Black Powder).
Of course, with our positive experience with Maurice, there had to be comparisons - good and bad. Main points of discussion that came to light included:
Having said all that, it's still a decent set of rules and will require more testing/playing- especially so where the projected AWI games are concerned. Warlord Games also do excellent scenario books - something which is lacking for the Maurice rules.
And so to battle:
A nice linear battlefield. A lot of cover and an epic cavalry battle promised on the French right.
View from the French right. Dragoons, cavalry and elite guard cavalry will meet head on.
On the Allied right, early command points enable a triple move from the Irish contingent against the prepared defences at Walcourt.
View from a pub in Walcourt.
In the centre, Allied dragoons, positioned unwisely perhaps, face off against three battalions of French dismounted dragoons.
...while the Irish remain too weak to assault the English units, and trade musketry.
The French centre is strengthened by the presence of the Gardes Francais, and delayed arrival of allied reinforcements means that they have to attack quickly.
French gunners cease fire as the latest copy of'The Sun' L'Equipe arrives.
View from the Allied command position in the centre.
The French assault comes on, as the elite Dutch guards watch its approach. The French attack was considerably hampered by poor activation rolls, and it took many turns for it to get under way. In Maurice, the problems would have been different - in that sections of the battlefield would have remained static (but still using musketry) as the focus was placed where it needed (or could be managed) to be. With these rules, there's more of a random element in terms of where the commander can focus his attention.
French dragoons capture the church in the centre.
...while a massive French cavalry attack gets underway.
On the Allied right, covered English regiments give accurate fire toward the bogged down Irish.
Cavalry charges go on for many turns on the right. The victor will be able to turn the flank - but so many units are involved.
(We actually ran out of markers for casualties - it was becoming a bloody stalemate.)
...as on the French left - all that is left of a unit in the all too brief assault is a bunch of markers as it fails its break test.
The high water marks of the French attack are the ground taken in the centre...
...and the gloire of the Gardes Francais , (although they're about to be forced to take a break test due to withering fire from the Dutch).
We didn't get a proper resolution to the scenario (although it was definitely going the Allies' way), and the rules will need a little more testing before using again - but all in all, a nice set and not too restrictive - although the command activation could use a little development. Having said that, we've probably been swayed a lot by the battlefield management style play of Maurice.
...while American Revolution troops wait in the wings (yes - keen eyed viewers will note only one American unit painted so far. I'm considering using the 'dip' method for the rest in order to get things moving.) We'll most likely try the Freeman's Farm scenario in the Black Powder rulebook as the first game.
...until next time.
Overall, the rules give a decent game - so we were less concerned with the actual history on this occasion, hoping to find a set of rules that could ultimately be used for the American War of Independence (Black Powder).
Of course, with our positive experience with Maurice, there had to be comparisons - good and bad. Main points of discussion that came to light included:
- The Pike & Shotte / Black Powder rules are straight forward and lend themselves to using multiple players, unlike Maurice, which is pure player vs player (despite its attempts to be otherwise).
- Although a good read over the rules is required, they are eminently 'pickup-able' with some classic mechanisms - including those (sometimes) unfortunate 'characteristic' style additions which have found their way from warhammer style rules. This is no surprise considering the authors involved of course. I say unfortunate, as these little advantages seem to get forgotten mid game, unless you have multiple players to remember the respective benefits and bonuses of their individual units.
- I missed the card mechanic of Maurice; although the Black Powder rules have a command mechanism which can (and ultimately did) considerably restrict the freedom of movement of brigades and battalia and tried to restrict movement and command, it seemed more random than with Maurice - where most of the time your turn was based on resource management and the restrictions that go with it; a player could spend barrels of cards just to make one thing happen if desperate enough, at the expense of everything else. With Pike & Shotte, you face the blind luck of a command dice roll, with some modifiers - although a better commander will get to do more of what he wants.
- Although appearing basic, hand to hand combat and charging takes longer, and is less intuitive, than Maurice.
- One issue with Maurice sometimes is that it is so fast that units disappear very quickly, leaving an almost empty battlefield (see the Boyne game last year for instance) - but that's purely a visual issue. That doesn't happen with P&S, as mauled units can still stay on the table if they pass a break test.
Having said all that, it's still a decent set of rules and will require more testing/playing- especially so where the projected AWI games are concerned. Warlord Games also do excellent scenario books - something which is lacking for the Maurice rules.
And so to battle:
A nice linear battlefield. A lot of cover and an epic cavalry battle promised on the French right.
View from the French right. Dragoons, cavalry and elite guard cavalry will meet head on.
On the Allied right, early command points enable a triple move from the Irish contingent against the prepared defences at Walcourt.
View from a pub in Walcourt.
...while the Irish remain too weak to assault the English units, and trade musketry.
The French centre is strengthened by the presence of the Gardes Francais, and delayed arrival of allied reinforcements means that they have to attack quickly.
French gunners cease fire as the latest copy of
View from the Allied command position in the centre.
The French assault comes on, as the elite Dutch guards watch its approach. The French attack was considerably hampered by poor activation rolls, and it took many turns for it to get under way. In Maurice, the problems would have been different - in that sections of the battlefield would have remained static (but still using musketry) as the focus was placed where it needed (or could be managed) to be. With these rules, there's more of a random element in terms of where the commander can focus his attention.
French dragoons capture the church in the centre.
...while a massive French cavalry attack gets underway.
On the Allied right, covered English regiments give accurate fire toward the bogged down Irish.
Cavalry charges go on for many turns on the right. The victor will be able to turn the flank - but so many units are involved.
(We actually ran out of markers for casualties - it was becoming a bloody stalemate.)
...as on the French left - all that is left of a unit in the all too brief assault is a bunch of markers as it fails its break test.
The high water marks of the French attack are the ground taken in the centre...
...and the gloire of the Gardes Francais , (although they're about to be forced to take a break test due to withering fire from the Dutch).
We didn't get a proper resolution to the scenario (although it was definitely going the Allies' way), and the rules will need a little more testing before using again - but all in all, a nice set and not too restrictive - although the command activation could use a little development. Having said that, we've probably been swayed a lot by the battlefield management style play of Maurice.
...while American Revolution troops wait in the wings (yes - keen eyed viewers will note only one American unit painted so far. I'm considering using the 'dip' method for the rest in order to get things moving.) We'll most likely try the Freeman's Farm scenario in the Black Powder rulebook as the first game.
...until next time.
Labels:
Black Powder,
Maurice,
Nine Years War,
Pike and Shotte
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



































