Sunday, 26 April 2020

Savannah 1779

I've wanted to do this battle since I saw Greg Novak's version with Volley & Bayonet, years ago. That was on his excellent blog, which has gone from us now with his untimely death in 2012. (I wish now that I'd saved his wargame pics from his refight / campaign).
 
I have placed his scenario for the battle/campaign with Volley and Bayonet at the end of this post - which I would prefer to use V&B 'proper' for at some stage.


This version was a quicker play in order to test some terrain and unit numbers, of course using Field of Battle. (3rd edition of this epic rule-set now out).

Savannah features a Franco-American attack on the British defended coastal town: Admiral d'Estaing and the American Maj Gen Benjamin Lincoln, would try to take the robust defensive positions that Swiss-born soldier of fortune, and commander of the British troops, Brigadier Augustine Prevost has put in place.


The town would be stormed by French and American troops who knew that time was running out. Not only were French ships rife with scurvy; but chances would increase with each passing day that French ships at anchor would be located and destroyed by the British fleet.

The scenario also features Irish troops in French service (and in redcoats), under Count Dillon, whose ancestors could be counted among the early flight of the first Wild Geese to leave Ireland for France, under McCarthy and Sarsfield in 1689 and 1691; ...and whose troops, in tandem with their French masters, might have found some dangerously revolutionary and rebellious ideas to take home with them whilst in the Americas, which could blossom into fruition a mere ten years later...(well, that's the theory).

 
(This version of the scenario based on the excellent version for British Grenadier in this scenarios book).

The actual battle would see 1,000 Franco-American casualties, with minimal losses among the British, whose defenses would prove nigh impregnable. The game would end in similar fashion...

 
It's just like the map above ....right?

 The Allies have good numbers, but Class III defences / trenches, and massed heavy guns, will give the British a massive advantage.

 In reality, the flanking maneuvers were mere demonstrations; in the game they would prove to be the main thrusts.

 The French and Americans had massed their cannon on the nearby high ground.

 ...with some early success, forcing redcoats back from the defences. But their success, would be short lived.

'Oh do take care down there dear. I'll just stay cosy on the ship shall I?'
 
 American assault on their left goes in.

 ...supported by Dillon's Franco-Irish.

 The centre seemed possible to take, ...until the British artillery opened up...

 A massive loss to the Americans however, as the excellent Brig Gen Laurens is killed by a cannonball.

 Massing for the assault on the left, even as Laurens' troops are put out of command in the attack is badly stalled, allowing British to pour fire on the massed battalions.

 French rout in the centre. The British cannon had all the luck here.

 The left becomes a morass, as Laurens' command are simply in the way now.

 Eventually the assault on the left would go in, but substantial losses on the flanks would be the order of the day...


 On the right, horrible casualties from cannon would be overcome to eventually permit an assault on the entrenched British.

It would be for naught however ...as morale points were bled away. The French hoped to get their attacks in before the Army Morale card came up. They pass one morale check, then fail the second, getting only one battalion within spitting distance of the town. They withdraw in frustration.


Another excellent game, and proof that troops good defences in FoB are extremely hard to shift.

Below is Greg Novak's excellent version of the wider scenario and campaign for V&B:


















18 comments:

  1. Great looking scenario Sir Duc, and the Flying Shadow is a fine vessel

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. She is Jack, thanks.
      I've kept her in the roofspace ever since my eldest daughter, at the age of 4, was determined that she wanted a pirate ship.
      I've held onto that bloody thing for 18 years now waiting to get it into a game LOL.

      Delete
  2. What a great looking game and what looks like a really fun scenario to play solo.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cheers.
      It's a strange scenario - historically even. accounts point to a lot of politics being played in the background, so you can play about with some of the command values.
      It's a tough nut to crack for the American/French side though.

      Delete
  3. It's my home town battle. Nice to see it on a tabletop. A bit more dramatic than the Ft. Pulaski shellacking / bombardment of the civil war.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Really? I had no idea. Many thanks. I hope I did it justice Ski.
      I neglected to mention include General Pulaski - though he would have been there as part of another unit due to scale; a fascinating character.

      Delete
    2. So I went onto google and dropped myself into your home town, Ski!
      I think I managed to find the hill where the French cannon were!
      Gawd bless the internet.

      Delete
  4. An interesting layout. Soon we will have FOB3 to enjoy !!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah - just waiting on Allen coming back with a paypal invoice ...I think.

      Delete
  5. Darren,

    Wow man, a heckuva fight, and really nice looking to boot! But the Yanks and French were robbed! ;)

    V/R,
    Jack

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Jack.
      Yeah - a lot of bad juju between the French and Americans - and of course, Irish regiments always have their own agenda LOL

      Delete
  6. What a fab table and lovely armies - enjoyed thanks.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Norm.
      Again, I am being tempted to go back to hexes though - simply by virtue of making things simpler and more immediately apparent in terms of terrain/attacks etc.

      Delete
  7. Wow looking good, Darren! AWI is definitely in the air, lately. I'm working on my 15mm British regulars now and reading Joseph Plumb Martin's book to boot! More please. I played Freemans Farm with the VB wing scale forces many years ago and it was great fun. I'll have to find that post.

    Also amphibious operations are rough by modern standards so all the more so in the 18th century!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Steve. Yes, it's a fascinating period for me. I've always been intrigued at the Ulster Scots' influence on the revolution vs the fact that Gaelic/old English Irish were drafted as redcoats - a complete reversal of what was happening 100 years beforehand in Ireland - happening in farwaway colonies, who would become a country in their own right. There's a massive connection with 'olde' Ireland there.

      There's a book out by Scott 'How the Old World Ended' which refers to Dutch and American influence on the development of British power in the 18th/19th centuries - but I don't think it goes far enough on how pivotal the AWI was in world history. It put many 'dangerous' ideas in the heads of potential 'revolutionaries' across the world and changed Europe's outlook completely - whether by accident or design - one could could argue that dangerous Ulstermen ultimately started the Napoleonic Wars (LOL I know - it's a stretch).

      I haven't read Plumb Martin's book - I really must sort that out.

      Delete
    2. ...and yeah. I need to get over to New Jersey and see those northern battlefields mate :)

      Delete
  8. Superb looking game, and given the obstacles faced by the attackers, perhaps best fought solo after all!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Gonslavo.
      Enjoyable game - FoB creates the right amount of tension and always delivers I think.

      Delete