Sunday, 1 September 2019

More Maurice - Speyerbach 1702

This game actually started out as a trial for the 3rd edition Warfare in the Age of Reason, which I picked up recently, though after set-up, and the realisation that despite the wonderfully traditional turn sequence, the chain-of-activation was based on a random card draw, we decided to abandon all hopes of trawling through rules that would boil down to a card draw to activate a random unit, and play the scenario with Maurice instead!

So, the set-up is based on the Battle of Speyerbach as featured in the WitAoR rule-book, but as I couldn't be bothered learning the rules, we regressed (read - 'advanced') back to Maurice.


Takeaways for this superlative rule-set include:
  • The Lethal Vollies national characteristic is either too lethal, either that or I seem to 'luck out' with the English each time we play hehehe; though I can see how, if used sparingly, it can be representative of platoon fire and British troops during AWI battles.
  • A la Baionette N.C. is adequately foiled by the Steady Lads N.C., even if the French get their charges in early.
  • Every time we play this set, the battlefield gets split!
Some nice classic Minifigs.

  • This game is about not having enough resource to do what you want! Period! Show me another set that does it as well. Granted, we see it in C&C but perhaps with a little more randomness. Only Field of Battle seems to grant the same degree of battlefield chaos.
  • By learning how to manipulate these rules, you inevitably learn how to fight on the C18th battlefield, because the design is so good - there, I said it!
Standard setup, little terrain.





This is where it gets weird, yet logical. French cavalry move on their right, foiled by a 'that's not on the map' card, that planks terrain in the way of the French charge, yet this slows things down really, as the French irregular cavalry (we're experimenting with how to classify dragoons) can get through. Predictably, this did foil the French flanking plan - which had repercussions later.


In response, the allies make cavalry moves on their right, which never quite amount to anything, whilst holding the French left in check throughout the battle. This is what I mean by forcing you to think in C18th terms. You simply can't do everything, but you can make the enemy think through non-engaging, 'classy' maneuvre.  



 The French centre maneuvers to adapt to the threat on their left, which started via their attack on the right.
 
 As musketry kicks in, the cards are flying.

Historically, we have been very bad at positioning commanders during their part of the turn. We now realise how critical it is, unless you want to waste away your best cards. The commander needs to be where the action is hottest so that he can use crappy cards to make a difference.

French still have high hopes of breaking the thin red line, (ok so it's a little early for that).

 ...but not with firing rolls like this...

Breakthrough? ...or will French hopes be focused on other areas of the battlefield for the balance of the game? (It's a rhetorical question...)

 The French can shoot well too, mind you.

 French/Irish mercenaries charge into the flank of Allied cavalry - but this splits the battlefield, and removes the focus from the French assault on the centre.


 ...allowing Allied units to snake round the flank and pour deadly vollies into the French, whose charge had been pushed back.


 




 Some nice classic MiniFigs and Dixon French.

 It's all gone to hell in the centre.

 The Allied right - where it's a stalemate; neither side wanting to risk a charge, as morale is wearing down.


 'I'm all over the place here,...'

 They think it's all over...
 

 ...it is now! Victory snatched from the proverbial jaws of being trounced...
 
 A great game. Each time we play this, there are more nuances and subtleties in the rules. You have to watch army morale, whilst pooling resources and pushing in the right place. It's a beautiful design, and each game seems to reveal a little more of the nuance of the game design.

Saturday, 10 August 2019

Gettysburg with 'BBB'


I've had Chris Pringle's 'Bloody Big Battles' for a while now. Although the is later C19th European battles, the system is equally applicable to ACW (and has been used for AWI and Napoleonics on the yahoo group and associated blogs - also see Chris's own blog here).




This is a great system. Now, it seems simple IGOUGO when you first read it, though bear in mind that it is divisions that are being manipulated as units, so entire actions can be re-fought.



Takeaways include:
  • The system is a 'lite' style version of F&F, with activation for units (but division based) BUT using 2D6 for a nice bell curve rather than the D10. It really works.
  • Generals move first, and can offer benefits, so care must be taken as to where they might provide influence.
  • It takes brave, bold moves to do things. Standing and firing will get you nowhere, but, by the same token, can nicely hold the enemy in place while you do some subtle maneuvering (as good Generals do during the period in question).
  • The system cuts out a lot of divisional and corps 'game management', in favour of allowing generalship.
  • Units are raw/trained/veteran and this can have subtle effect on their ability to stand and become 'spent' etc. We found Reb units quite solid, while Union units were highly variable in our game.

  • Forces are 20mm plastic on 1.5" bases. 1" bases are recommended in the rules - and granted, things were a little cramped on a 6'x4', but still worked. 
  • All three days of battle were represented here, with night turns for consolidation, and some movement. Day One: turns 1-3; Day Two: turns 4-8; Day Three: turn 9-11.

 Gettysburg from the south.

Buford at top of pic, with initial Union forces.


 Early attacks on Buford's position.

 'I feel we shall win the day suh!'


Reb attacks in the centre, piecemeal at first.

 ...but gaining momentum.

Longstreet makes first assaults on the Union left.

 ...while the Union (foolishly) opt to try to hold on to Gettysburg on the first day.

 
 Union reinforcements begin to move on the left, though their dice rolls are horrible, and gaining the high ground is a close run thing.

 Keep pushin' boys... 
 Rebs move toward the Round tops (lower pic) and Cemetary Ridge rapidly.


 ...but last minute Union efforts from multiple Corps secure the high ground just in time.

 ...as Rebs flow through Gettysburg towards a somewhat limited Union force on Cemetary Hill.

 First assault against Round Top. (Little Round Top remains unmanned for many hours).


 After vicious fighting, Longstreet's forces take the hill, but can not hold onto it, as two Union divisions subsequently counterattack.



 The Union left is secure.

 ...further north however, their right flank is under considerable threat.




 A massive Union reinforcement on Turn 9 however, is enough to push the Rebs back before they can get behind Union positions - a very close run thing.



 
 Too late JEB!


A great system, with lots of potential. Will be interesting to see how well it works with Waterloo/Napoleonics, as I don't see any real issue with rules at this level, and certainly there seem to be some good examples of other periods across the web.

Today's musical number is wierdly in tune with the game (don't ask).
LOOK AWAY IF YOU HAVE A FEAR OF CLOWNS (or similar):




  ADDENDUM - Scenario and OOB from the BBB Yahoo Group: